This sewing project is for making a reversible pie plate cozy from cotton fabric with extra fabric for the handle, the perfect item to make for the holiday season.

Use This Guide To Make Pie Pan Cozy

If you made the bowl cozy already, you would want to make this pie pan cozy. Or use it as a pie plate carrier for your next potluck party.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links. Please see the Disclosure Policy for details.

There are many pie plate sizes, but most pie recipes use the 9″ diameter pan. This cozy is for a 9″ Pyrex pie pan because that is the pie pan I use most of the time.

I also have the 9,5″ pie plate, which fits on the cozy.

The two pointy corners on the opposite side also act as the handle when you lift the pie plate. Also, to protect your hand when you hold the hot pie plate handle.

Supply To Make A Pie Plate Cozy

You will get one pie plate cozy from two sheets of fat quarter fabric and three cozies from one-yard fabric.

Use 100% cotton fabric, batting, and thread if you plan to use it in the microwave. I used cotton quilt fabric for this project.

• 2 sheets of fat quarter cotton fabric
• Pie plate cozy pattern (if you want to use a template so you can skip the measuring process)
• 100% cotton batting, the cotton Pellon Wrap N Zap is a batting specifically for an item to use in a microwave
• 100% cotton thread
• Disappeared fabric marker, I always use the dual-purpose fabric marker.
• Quilting clips
• Pins
• Chopstick
• Scissors
• Sewing machine
• Ironing machine

Easy Pie Plate Cozy Tutorial

If you want to watch the video tutorial instead, click here for the Pie Plate Cozy video tutorial on my YouTube channel and subscribe for more videos.

Cut the materials into these measurements if you don’t use the pie plate cozy template (available here).

Cut the fabric into two sheets 13 inches square each.
Cut the batting into two sheets 13 inches square each.

Put one fabric with the right side facing down, and put one sheet of batting on top of it.

Mark diagonal lines to connect each opposite corner.
Fold the material in half, and mark the folding spot.
Draw a line to connect the folding spot.

Pin the material or use quilting clips.
Sew straight along both diagonal lines.

To measure the dart or triangle area, mark 1″ left and right from the folding line. Mark 2.5″ from the edge inward along the folding line.

Connect the line between each marked spot into a triangle shape.
Repeat the process to make four darts.

Fold the material in half on the folding line. Pin it or use the quilting clip.
Sew the connected triangle lines on all four sides.

Trim the extra fabric on the dart about 0.5″ from the stitched line.
Repeat the process of measuring and sewing for the other piece of cozy.

Use quilting clips or pin both sides of the pie plate cozy and the right side of both fabrics facing each other.

Put the pie plate on it, and draw a curve line on two opposite sides about 0.75″ from the pie plate rim, starting from the dart line to the next one.

Cut the cozy on these curve lines.

Remove the pie plate, use quilting clips or pin the cozy together. Draw the line 0.5″ along the edge for seam allowance.

Sew along the seam allowance and skip 3″ for the opening gap.

Clip both pointy corners to reduce bulk.

Turn the cozy right side out. Use the chopstick to push each pointy corner and smooth the curve side.

Press the cozy with the ironing machine.

Topstitch the pie plate cozy along the hem and close the opening gap.

The pie plate cozy is ready to use.

Make this pie plate cozy from fabric, quick and easy tutorial #pieplatecozy #pieplateholder Share on X

This 9-inch pie plate cozy is perfect for the holiday season to serve the delicious pie you bake for the gathering. My favourite one is huckleberry pie, what’s yours?

If your pie plate has a handle, then position the handle by the pointy corner.

This pie plate holder is reversible so that you can use both sides.

Get the PDF

If it is more convenient to have the printable version of this tutorial for the project, you can purchase the Printable PDF format of Reversible Pie Plate Cozy Template And Sewing Tutorial here. The e-book has the template and complete tutorials with pictures included. There are no ads or video displays on the PDF so that you can print it, and it will be available for you anytime you need the tutorial for your next project. Click on the e-book cover image above to purchase.

More sewing projects for the kitchen

• Casserole Dish Cozy
• Large Hot Pad
• Ice Cream Cozy
• Reversible Bowl Cover
• Self Binding Cloth Napkins
• Easy Binding Mug Rug
• Tortilla Warmer Bag

DIY Pie Plate Cozy From Fabric